A Fellowship is formed: thoughts post-Conference.

FrodoRingGreetings Fellowship,

It is our hope this finds you all well. We took a bit of a break post-conference and have had everyone in mind since then. There have been a great number of positive responses to the Conference and we hope you all enjoyed the program we put together. We would be very grateful for any comments and suggestions we can use to better the next Conference. Please comment below or fill out the comments box at the end of this article.

We cannot thank you all enough for your support– the donations and attendance at the first New York Tolkien Conference. It is very heartwarming to know how far some traveled to attend and present at this event.

To our Guests of Honor Janet Brennan Croft and John DiBartolo and the Lonely Mountain Band: we are incredibly grateful for your support, your dedication, and your being the 1st Guests of Honor to launch this Conference. We cannot express our gratitude enough for everything you did to make this a very special experience for us all.

The first NY Tolkien Conference was even more special since it was the first live performance of The Lonely Mountain Band. If you missed this here’s a sample of their work in 3 songs to download for free:

We encourage you all, regardless of your attendance, to Google each of our presenters and check out their work in the Tolkien field, and other areas they are published within.

Poster_Small_NYTolkCon3To our friend and Illustrator Luke Spooner

Thank you so very much for the Conference image and all the work you have done for Myth Ink Books.  The event image you produced thrust us all right into Middle-earth for an adventure. Thank you.

Please be sure to check out Luke’s work here

As for next Conference, please be patient with us as we continue to develop our plans


for the next Conference. If you wish to stay up to date on news of the next Conference, or plans for the 2015 Proceedings please see the subscribe box at the top of the right column

If you missed any of the talks and wished to read an essay from our presenters, or could not attend this year’s Conference, then also please subscribe for our updates about the forthcoming Proceedings.  The Proceedings will be published via Myth Ink Books and available via and be available for distribution in physical stores. Our Independent Press Myth Ink Books also ships all their titles via this online store

Did you miss the presentations by Dawn Walls-Thumma or Rebecca Glass & Kat Fanning?

Two of our presenters recorded their talks and have posted them online, below are the videos of each of these presentations

The abstract, presenter bio is below with a few words from Dawn Walls-Thumma who cites the below on her blog found here:

The Loremasters of Fëanor: Historical Bias in the Works of J.R.R. Tolkien and Transformative Works

The video of my New York Tolkien Conference presentation “The Loremasters of Fëanor: Historical Bias in the Works of J.R.R. Tolkien and Transformative Works” has been posted on my YouTube channel. A detailed synopsis–including the data that you won’t be able to see on the Powerpoint behind me unless you have eyes like the Elves–can be found on my blog The Heretic Loremaster. I’d love to hear comments there or here; I am hoping to make this topic into something publishable in the very near future.

My paper begins by exploring how the construction of Tolkien’s works creates in-universe historical bias that affects interpretation of the texts. I specifically look at how the writings of Pengolodh would have shown bias toward the House of Fëanor. While most Tolkien scholars have overlooked this historical bias, it has become a key component of the approach many fan fiction writers take when creating stories about Tolkien’s world. I look at evidence that supports the idea that historical bias inspires fan fiction and consider some major ways that authors use the fallible, biased in-universe narrators to deepen and build on Tolkien’s world through the creation of transformative works.

In 1992, Alex Lewis presented a paper at the J.R.R. Tolkien Centenary Conference in Oxford, England, in which he made the argument that Tolkien’s Silmarillion was constructed to reflect the political biases of the fictional chronicler of the text: Elrond. Lewis shows that characters affiliated with Elrond tend to receive more treatment in the text, and their actions are cast in a positive light, whereas characters outside of Elrond’s lineage—Lewis focuses specifically on the Fëanorians—receive relatively little coverage of their positive actions and tend to be depicted negatively by the narrator.

Lewis’s findings have been almost wholly ignored by Tolkien scholars, despite the implications of his findings for how The Silmarillion could be read as a work of history therefore subject to historiological considerations. However, another group that deeply reads, studies, and analyzes Tolkien’s texts has not only made a similar observation as Lewis but has acted, often significantly, upon those observations: writers of Tolkien-based transformative fiction, or fan fiction. Walls-Thumma is in the midst of conducting a survey of Tolkien fan fiction writers, and preliminary results show that this group is deeply committed to the study of Tolkien’s world in order to write fiction set in that world. These writers often express a desire to explore the perspectives of characters either ignored or maligned in the texts and sometimes write with the explicit purpose of righting the historical record where misrepresented characters are concerned.

This paper will consider how Tolkien’s construction of historical bias in his books influences the creation of transformative fiction based on those books. Lewis claims that part of the reason The Silmarillion is so compelling is because it mirrors the complexity of real-world history, including in the presence of political bias. The types of fan fiction being written about Tolkien’s books and the often inverse relationship between the characters Tolkien emphasized and the characters fan fiction authors write about suggests that the presence of political bias in the texts is a driving force behind the creation of transformative works. Fan fiction writers often view Tolkien’s books as historical texts and their own role as providing alternative texts within the historical record, using subtextual and intertextual analyses to construct stories that offer alternative readings consist with Tolkien’s larger canon. Finally, this activity suggests that Tolkien was successful, despite his doubts, in creating what he termed in a letter to Milton Waldman “vast backcloths” of myth and history that would inspire other creators.

Dawn Walls-Thumma is the founder and owner of the Silmarillion Writers’ Guild and a moderator on Many Paths to Tread and Back to Middle-earth Month, projects that promote a deeper understanding of Tolkien’s world through the creation of transformative works set in that world. She is perilously close to finishing her MA in Humanities at American Public University. Dawn has presented on Tolkien’s cosmogony and Tolkien-based fan fiction at the Mythmoot II and III conferences, and her research on the Tolkien fan fiction community has been published in Mythprint.

Did you miss…?

History & Technique:  Sourcing the Arms, Armor and Fighting Techniques of Middle-earth

Presented by Rebecca Glass and Kat Fanning

Tolkien’s universe is filled with example of special arms and armor that possess special importance, from Frodo’s mithril shirt to Anduril and Glamdring. But what is the historical basis for these examples of arms and armor? How did they impact the fighting techniques of the time? What sources do we have that describe the way people fought in the late Middle Ages? This presentation will make use of historical sources — such as references to exhibits of surviving weapons and armor, as well as to the preserved fechtbucher (fighting manuals) and their commentaries that are available to anyone interested — to show how we are able to recreate historical fencing techniques. The presentation will also distinguish between blossfechten and harnisfechten (armored vs unarmored combat) and briefly discuss why the sword fights we see in movies (using the Lord of the Rings movies as an example) are often inaccurate. Video clips of Historical European Martial Arts bouts will be presented.

Rebecca Glass is a graduate of Syracuse University and a member of the New York Historical Fencing Association. When she’s not swordfighting, she volunteers with the CVTC program at St Luke’s-Roosevelt and writes for

Kat Fanning has been studying Historical European Martial Arts since 2014. She is a specialty pharmacy facility supervisor by profession. Additionally, she is a pre-program intern in the conservation department of the Center for Jewish History. She graduated from Southern Connecticut State University in 2011 with a BA in Art History and Chemistry.

We look forward to gathering again with you all for the 2016 New York Tolkien Conference and hope you all will stay in touch via email, or social media, which our Facebook Group for attendees, presenters and anyone else can be found here: NY Tolkien Conference Facebook Group

Please send us feedback on anything you wish via this comment box: (Be Nice and gentle hobbitses)

3 thoughts on “A Fellowship is formed: thoughts post-Conference.

  1. Thank you so much for linking to my video here! And for having me and my rebellious Feanorians in the first place. 🙂 One nitpick … there is a wee typo in my name: It is WAlls-Thumma, not Wells-Thumma.

    This was a wonderful event; I had a great time and hope to make the trek northward again next year too. I’m thrilled to hear that you all plan to run it again. Quite a few people were jealous to hear about it once I returned, so I’m trying to stir up their interest for next year. There go those Feanorians again … 😉

    Kudos to Anthony and Jessica and everyone else who planned and ran this event! You did a great job!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.